The Illusion of Victory by Thomas Fleming. Not as entertaining as his
Duel but still a provocative anti-Wilson and pro-German view of America's involvement in WWI.
Imperial Germany is beleagured by the equally aggrandizing, imperialistic, and hypocritical France and England. Wilson is self-righteous and stubborn yet vacillating and unprincipled.
And definitely a divider, not a uniter! Wilson constantly complains about hyphenated Americans, who he views as disloyal, and has this to say about his Congressional opponents:
[it was] not their character so much that I have contempt for, though that contempt is thoroughgoing, but their minds. They do not even have working imitations of minds." (p. 347)
Fleming refers to Wilson perjoratively as Phillip Dru: the hero of
Phillip Dru, Administrator written by Wilson's alter-ego Colonel House. Dru is an uber-bureaucratic fantasy President who leads a turbulent nation out of chaos. Think of it as a Progressive Era
West Wing.Fleming has worse things to say about the First Lady
Edith Galt Wilson--controlling, possessive, minimally educated, with a high self-regard of her political wisdom.
History has revised and re-revised Wilson. However, is bitter opponent,
Teddy Roosevelt, is still adored. Yet modern Bull Mooses rarely talk about TR's
vigorous war-mongering attempts to push the U.S. into the First World War. Although Fleming is hostile toward U.S,. entry into the war, he treats him lightly. TR's cousin,
FDR, is a different story. He is a philandering, back-stabber given to telling Clintonian whoppers: telling a Butte, Montana audience that he
wrote the constitution for Haiti. The Great War was a particularly horrible and stupid episode in history. Fleming's book is the best I have read at evoking the horrible stupidity. One of the great mysteries of history is how Western civilization, at one of its apogees, chose to descend into a period of vicious barbarism.
Although the Progressives were believers in scientific management of society, their administration of a wartime economy were a disaster: inflation, strikes, millions of dollars spent without building a single plane, soldiers without overcoats dying of influeza in U.S. camps. Their efforts descended to the tragicomic when they called on
Harvard students to act as strikebreakers. Crimson clad frat-boys and jocks first tried to act as telephone operators, then as replacements for Boston cops. The city's roughnecks beat them to a pulp. (Using students as strikebreakers was
common at the time.)
Also egregiously incompetent were American military commanders who apparently did not modify their tactics since the Civil War. (Which is true of most other military commanders at the time.) The tactic of attacking machine guns en masse resulted in 50,300 deaths in six months of combat. Compare this to 259,376 killed over 47 months in WWII, and 57,000 dead in eleven years in Vietnam.
The decline of political violence. Fleming highlights the shocking level of political violence in the U.S. at the time. One example: on the first anniversary of Armistice day, a group from the American Legion, armed with baseball bats and pistols, aims to clear out the nest of Bolsheviks at the IWW local. The union members defend themselves by shooting back. The mob lynches and castrates the union leader Wesley Everett, who is also a veteran.
Maybe I'm cocooned, but even the altercations of Anne Coulter, Al Franken, et al. rarely reach such levels of violence. Maybe the answer is economic. Maybe the opportunity cost of mob violence has risen. After all, potential members of the rabble have to drive to the assembly place and find parking for their SUVs. And between taking the kids to soccer practice, and working out the gym, who has time to join a mob?
The decline, yes decline, of ethnic politics. German-, Irish-, and Italian- Americans all campaigned vigorously against Wilson and the Versailles treaty because it shortchanged their ancestral homes. What would Michelle Malkin make of that?
The decline of the politics of personal destruction. You have probably already heard that during the 1920 presidential election Democrats circulated a pamphlet written by a history professor alleging that Warren Harding had "Negro blood." However, Republicans slimed back. They alleged that vice-presidential candidate FDR's handling of a Navy sodomy scandal while he was assistant secretary of the Navy demonstrated a lack of "the qualities of frankness and manliness," i.e. he was gay.
The decline of the German-Americans. In the research for my book, I constantly ran across evidence of the power of the German-American community. Affluent and educated, they constantly fought against state school systems to preserve their language and culture. If a group opposed the expansion of the local common schools, it was either the Germans or the Catholics. German was once the most common modern langauge taught as a second langauge in the schools. This struggle climaxed during WWI as Americans were incited to a pitch of vicious war hatred against their German neighbors. This is often glossed over with a reference to Liberty Cabbage, but it often resulted in violence, murder, and even suicide.
Finally,there is the bizarre, Kurosawa-like climax to the era as the First Lady, with the complicity of the President's doctors, close aides, and reporters, attempts to deceive the nation into believing that Wilson, paralyzed and incapacitated by a stroke, still has the capacity to manage the country and even run for a third term.